Julie Holm's Blog
Thoughts as I figure out what to say now that I've finished my final paper on bonhoeffer.
Friday September 3, 2010
Posted by: Juliana Holm at 8:03AM EST on September 3, 2010
This week, Patrick J. Wilson, in his lectionary blog for The Christian Century, shared a wonderful meditation on the body, even the ailing body, being "fearfully and wonderfully made." What timing this blog entry was for me, as I finish my second week of radiation!
It is easy, isn't it, to wonder at the body that excels: the fabulous major league pitcher, the amazing little gymnast, the willowy beautiful model, even the local aerobics instructor captures our attention and amazement. But these days I am just as aware of the wonder of my own body. ... (more)Tuesday August 24, 2010
Posted by: Juliana Holm at 9:04AM EST on August 24, 2010
On Trinity Sunday my pastor, Verne Arens gave a fantastic sermon on the doctrine of the Trinity. (No, really!) Among the things that it specifically discussed was how we experience God in different ways through different circumstances, and that some of these ways are expressed well by this doctrine. Another thing he discussed is that some of us have a particular affinity for specific persons of the Trinity.
I am definitely a Holy Spirit person. I feel most alive when I am creative - when new things are blowing through me and I am inspired. This is particularly true when I am experiencing new forms of connectedness and relationship. After all one theological approach to the Holy Spirit is through the connectedness of the persons of God! But this morning, laying on the radiation table, praying, I realized I direct prayer for healing to God as the Creator, the one who calls me into being. Or perhaps to a different persona of sort - a beloved image from my childhood as a Roman Catholic (though this is not a strictly Roman Catholic Image) of the great physician. This is particularly true in these days when my life is touched by so many caring, committed, capable, and surely called health professionals! ... (more)Sunday August 1, 2010
Posted by: Juliana Holm at 4:17PM EST on August 1, 2010
The class ended, my last paper is in, and graded, and back, and for the next three weeks I get to sit back, relax, and not worry too much about anything. Then in three weeks, I pack up my full time IBM consultant suitcase one last time (I will continue part time, as much for the opportunity to continue on their health care plan as anything else) and head back to school, to fieldwork.
But I want to take a minute to look back at some of the experience of Bonhoeffer. Outside of the study, what was the experience of this independent/directed study like?
... (more) Tuesday July 27, 2010
Posted by: Juliana Holm at 5:05PM EST on July 27, 2010
I love movies. For about 6 years I ran a summer movie program at my church "Film and Faith." So, I recently watched the made-for-PBS movie "Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Agent of Grace" which was made about Bonhoeffer's life in the conspiracy to kill Hitler. I thought I'd note a few things about it.
I thought that the movie, though was incredibly telescoped. Whole sections of the life of B that had relevance were telescoped into a word or two - and a huge amount was left out. In some cases it would have been very difficult to understand who someone was without already knowing the life of Bonhoeffer. That said, there were a couple of things that really came out very clearly here. First was the sheer youth of Maria Von Wedermeyer. She was a mere 19 year old thing, engaged to a man 20 years her senior. If he weren't in prison it would almost be uncomfortable. I hadn't thought about that before. The second was the reluctance to really get involved, and the sheer amount of inner struggle over what to do between 1939 and the fall of France. Bethge presents it as almost an instantaneous decision, but the letters that Bonhoeffer writes around his trip to New York in 1939 present someone very much wrestling with what to do. I really liked that the movie started out with him in New York, playing Spirituals on the piano with an African American friend (presumably Frank Fisher). In a real experience of gaity and a very emotional moment, just before heading back to Germany. This really places the story in a context that makes huge sense for me. The movie is very much about the ethical struggle. I can recommend it, if you know something about Bonhoeffer. If you don't - watch the 2003 documentary BEFORE watching "Agent of Grace." You'll get more out of the latter. Thursday July 8, 2010
Posted by: Juliana Holm at 1:12PM EST on July 8, 2010
One of Bonhoeffer's primary themes in Ethics is the concept that the worldly and the spiritual are inseparable; that the spiritual people cannot retreat from the world, and that the world is reconciled to God in Christ's redeeming action. Indeed Bonhoeffer writes movingly of the unity of the profane and the sacred throughout ethics. Indeed this discussion is how his Ethik begins.
In part this is a response to the church of his day, which relied on Martin Luther's doctrine of Two Kingdoms (Zwei Reiche) to keep the secular and the sacred specifically separate, and to ignore much of what was going on in the secular space, which allowed the church to remain silent in the face of the Third Reich and Adolph Hitler. Even worse, the National Socialists enforced their own kind of unity of profane and sacred in taking over the leadership of the German Church, installing a Reich Bishop, and essentially co-opting the spiritual lives of the German People. Bonhoeffer, who was a part of the leadership of the breakaway Confessing Church, and who was part of the ecumenical movement for peace, not only separated himself from the German Christians, who stayed with the protestant churches as the Nazis took over, but indeed even felt that the Confessing Church was too accomodating to the threat, trying to save itself rather than speak out too loud. Only the students that Bonhoeffer taught at the Finkenwalde Seminary and later through the Collective Pastorates in Pomerania were anywhere close to where Bonhoeffer was, which was one reason that he ended up in a largely secular and military conspiracy to assassinate Hitler. ... (more)Monday July 5, 2010
Posted by: Juliana Holm at 10:39AM EST on July 5, 2010
Yesterday we visited the Gedenkstaette Flossenbuerg (excuse the spelling, but I can't get umlauts in the body of the UCC blog) one of Germany's memorial to the reality of Concentration Camps. This was not my first visit to one of these memorials; we've visited Buchenwald and Auschwitz/Birkeneau as a family, and I visited Sachenhausen in 2005 when studying in Berlin. This trip we'll visit two more - Flossenbuerg, and most likely Dachau.
... (more) Thursday June 24, 2010
Posted by: Juliana Holm at 9:05AM EST on June 24, 2010
I've not posted recently, since I've been excessively busy, but I expect to more regularly over the next two weeks. I did a paper on Bonhoeffer's approach to the Book of Psalms. My prof asked a couple of really good questions in his response to it, which I plan to respond to in this forum. All I need is time. :-) I've continued reading, of course, getting through Letters and Papers from Prison, and am planning to do my next paper (again 5-7 pages) on the biblical basis of Religionless Christianity. One quick note on the Bible-centeredness of all this. First of all, Bonhoeffer was very bible-centered, in that tradition from Luther, and he connected with the earlier work of Luther, out of which much of the "scripture alone" part of the Lutheran approach to religion (fueled by the paradigm change coming out of the printing press). So it's important on that basis. From another POV, the prof directing my study is a bible prof, so the focus on the biblical hermeneutic of B. is part of the way this course is set up. I am looking forward to taking my exploration of Bonhoeffer further in the fall, when I take Systematic Theology, and can get deeper into that point of view. On to the real point. Also have read several portions of the Cambridge Companion to Bonhoeffer, including one on personal spirituality which echoed amazingly my first paper! Second paper on religionless Christianity focuses on the Bible basis, and I think I have a good handle on this - but I am also intruigued by other questions associated with this. Most notably, B's concepts have real resonance for the Church in our time, and particularly for the Church Vitality initiative. If B is right, then we need to become a "Religionless" Church, and I think that this is something that the UCC is indeed doing, using Bonhoeffer's way of looking at it. I don't have time today to think this through, but I will shortly, and will post on this topic. For the next two weeks I'll be on vacation - but I hope to connect and to post to this blog while away. This is important, because my vacation includes three important Bonhoeffer sites: The church where he did his first pastoral work in Barcelona, the Ettal monastery where much of what became Ethics was written, and the Concentration Camp at Flossenbuerg, where he was executed. I hope to post impressions and pictures of all these sites, and of course several B-related books will be in my backpack as I enjoy some rest and relaxation. |
|